<img src="https://certify.alexametrics.com/atrk.gif?account=3HHNq1DlQy20Y8" style="display:none" height="1" width="1" alt="">

SAP Analytics
Thought Leadership

BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA: FAQs

Posted by
Steve Sussman
Steve Sussman
on Sun, Jan 08, 2023 @ 11:01 AM
Featured Blog Photo-11.pngOn the surface, BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA appears to have many of the same features as the previous version, BPC 10.1.  However, the most meaningful upgrade in BPC 11 lies in the database platform, BW/4HANA.

To appreciate the new foundation for BPC 11, we have to explore the underlying database platform.  BW/4HANA may share a similar name with its predecessor, however, this all-new platform represents SAP’s rearchitected, next-generation data warehouse.

Let’s explore this new platform by directly addressing five key commonly asked questions:


1. Is “BW on HANA” the same as BW/4HANA?

No.  BW on HANA is an option for the previous versions of BPC, while BW/4HANA is the only option for BPC 11 and is only available for the current version of BPC.  BW/4HANA is not available for the BPC Microsoft version or any other BPC NetWeaver version prior to BPC 11.

2. Can BPC Optimized for S/4HANA use BW/4HANA? 

As this article is written, BPC Optimized for S/4HANA leverages the traditional version of BW and does not use BW/4HANA.  A common misnomer is the use of the word “data replication.”  We need to be clear - no version of BPC has ever “replicated data” from a general ledger or detailed transaction system.  BPC uses an OLAP, multidimensional database that summarizes transaction data in order to optimize reporting and analysis.  BPC 11 integrates with S/4HANA for traditional synchronization of master data dimensions and hierarchies, and to import/summarize transaction data in S/4HANA. 

BPC Optimized for S/4HANA does not need to perform the traditional synchronization of master data dimensions and hierarchies and also does not import/summarize the transaction data.  Many have interpreted that fact as the primary reason to support the conclusion that BPC Optimized for S/4HANA is the version that they should use, however, there are other details that need to be considered prior to coming to that conclusion.  In this article, we will summarize the major factors that need to be considered before selecting a version of BPC (see Question #4).  Later this year, we will release a detailed blog on all aspects of BPC Optimized for S/4HANA.

3. Does BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA support both Standard and Embedded models?

Yes, BPC 11 version for BW/4HANA supports both Standard and Embedded models.  From a front-end perspective, BPC Embedded models use the Analysis Plug-in as the Excel add-in, while Standard models use the EPM Plug-in (successor from the EPM Add-in).  From a technical perspective, Embedded models use a multi-key figure structure, while Standard models use a single chart of accounts structure.  Also, from an administrative perspective, Embedded models typically require more technical expertise that tend to veer outside of a functional business user.  However, BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA introduces a new set of graphical modeling tools (Eclipse) that make modeling in BW much easier and closer to being owned and managed by a functional business user.

4. What are the major differences between BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA and BPC Optimized for S/4HANA?

To summarize the differences, BPC Optimized for S/4HANA has two specific use cases today:

  1. Financial planning for customers where primary dimensions exist in the S/4HANA Universal Journal.
  2. Customers interested in performing real time consolidations.

BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA provides financial planning for customers, leveraging financial and operational data from within the BW/4HANA data warehouse and external data sources.

Also, a major difference between BPC Optimized and BPC 11 exists in ownership and maintenance.  BPC 11 continues the tradition of BPC ownership and responsibility falling mainly in the hands of the functional business users, while BPC Optimized typically involves more IT resources and specialized skills.

5. If my organization does not have BW expertise, will we need to hire or outsource IT talent to support BPC 11?

No. BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA introduces a new set of graphical modeling tools (Eclipse) that make modeling in BW much easier and closer to being owned and managed by a functional business user.  BW/4HANA was designed to be more efficient (less tables) and more user friendly.

BPC 11 provides new opportunities for cloud deployment with options to leverage AWS (Amazon Web Services), Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud Services and SAP HANA Enterprise Cloud (HEC).  Column5 provides a range of support options through out Managed Service practice along with hosting/cloud deployment options via our Technical Services team.

  Watch our free, on-demand BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA webinar to experience this upgrade and hear the product's roadmap directly from SAP!
view now


In summary,  BW/4HANA is SAP’s next-generation data warehouse platform that has been simplified and optimized for HANA.  It was designed around the following four core principles:

  • Simplicity – this includes simplified planning models in BW/4HANA with streamlined data load processes
  • High Performance – in BPC 11 the calculations are pushed down to HANA for faster planning and closing cycles along with improved scalability to plan with greater details
  • Openness – the ability and flexibility to integrate data from cloud applications or third party data into  BPC and more easily leverage Big Data to improve decision-making
  • Modern Interface – improved web interface, graphical BW Modeling tools, and deeper integration with SAP Analytics Cloud providing the ability to present live BPC data in SAP Digital Boardroom

There are also improvements on the functional side with BPC 11.  To expand on more detail related #4 above (modern interface) , the most obvious improvement on the functional side is in the web interface.  SAP provided a much-needed upgrade to the web interface, making it more modern, easier to navigate, while providing better usability for users.  BPC 11 introduces a new version of the HTML5 web interface that introduces a new home page that uses Fiori-based concepts with tiles that allows the user to drag and drop three types of assets on the home page.  The assets can be arranged and resized based on personal preferences.  The assets include:

  1. Upgraded Favorites panel
  2. My Activity panel - an enhanced process status which organizes Business Process Flow activities
  3. Upgraded charts providing interactive visualizations for analysis





For those using BPC for consolidations, there is a new Equity Pick-up Monitor available in the web interface to add to the consolidation capabilities.

Interested in integration strategies? In our blog article, “Using SAP Analytics Cloud as a Client to BPC," we explored several use cases that outlined integration scenarios with BPC.  BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA helps to take the integration with SAP Analytics Cloud to the next level with near real-time synchronization and providing the ability to update BPC from SAP Analytics Cloud.

We invite you to reach out to Column5 for more details about BPC 11, version for BW/4HANA for a detailed discussion around your specific needs and requirements, along with a detailed demonstration about this exciting new version and platform of BPC.

Related Articles:

steve-circle.gifAuthor Bio:

Steve Sussman oversees Column5´s global sales, business development and marketing initiatives. He has more than 20 years of experience in the EPM industry, including 6 years at Hyperion and over 5 years at OutlookSoft/SAP in sales and marketing related roles.

Steve delivers a wealth of experience through his highly educational, consultative approach. His unique ability to partner with visionary executives from a who´s who of leading global organizations has played a vital role in helping them transform their companies to achieve new heights. Under Steve´s direction, Column5´s sales team focuses on educating clients to appreciate sources of value, rather than strictly emphasizing technical specifications. In this way, Steve´s contributions reach far beyond sales — he has served as a career counselor and collaborator for many company leaders, and helped them achieve personal advancement by driving business results from their successful EPM initiatives.

Steve Sussman, Vice President, Marketing and Sales,  Column5 Consulting

Topics: Product Focused, BPC 11, Version for BW/4HANA


Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

see all

3  S T E P S

To Enhance Your EPM Performance:

 1.Get Your Ultimate Guide to Improving SAP EPM Performance

ebook 2

 Learn what could be contributing to your poor performance and how to diagnose common problems. Get tips that will empower you and your team to improve the  performance  of your system in order to get the most out of your SAP EPM Investment.

Get the e-Book


2.  Test Your BPC Performance 

Benchmark 2

Get a BPC performance report card and custom report to identify performance issues you may not even know you have.

Test my BPC


  3. Get Your EPM Assessment  


Our assessment delivers a complete, best practice roadmap for you to follow.  We’ll work together to assess what you need to pivot your financial forecasting, planning, reporting and analysis to handle the compressed requirements from the volatile COVID-19 environment. 

New Assessment